ai.fadeadeniyi‹ All guides
Free Guide

The Brutal Truth About Your 500 Sign-Ups

Why your price usually isn't the problem, how to find the action your paying users took early and how to get every new sign-up there in their first session.

3 steps  ·  3 prompts for Claude  ·  comment SIGNUP for the guide
Fadé Adeniyi
Fadé Adeniyi
Sunday 1 November 2026
Download the PDF Read it below, or take the PDF with you
START HERE

Why do 500 sign-ups turn into 3 paying customers?

You launch, the sign-ups come in and the numbers look great. Then you check how many of them are paying and it's a handful. The first thing most founders reach for is the price. They cut it, add a discount or stretch the trial.

Your price is usually never the problem, because most sign-ups never get to that paywall. They sign up, hit a wall of forms and set-up screens and leave before they've seen the one thing that would've made paying feel obvious.

I've spent 16 years in product, understanding the product market. I also built my own product, Xeruit, a jobs platform. Our pre-launch ad campaign got 3,000 sign-ups in less than three days. I found that ad's message by reading competitors' angriest 1-star and 2-star reviews. Most of those sign-ups weren't paying. That's what these three steps fix.

01 · Find the early action
Work out what your paying users did first
02 · Cut everything in between
Remove every step between sign-up and that action
03 · Track the first session
Count who reaches that action before they leave
Before you touch your price

Look at where people drop off first. If most sign-ups never reach the paywall, a lower price won't change anything because they'll never see it.

The 3 steps

01STEP · FIND THE ACTION

What did your paying users do early on?

prompt for claude
I'm attaching an export of my users. Each row shows whether they pay (yes/no) and the actions they took in their first 7 days, with timestamps.
1. Compare paying and non-paying users.
2. List the 5 actions most common among payers and least common among non-payers, with the share of each group that took them.
3. Tell me which single action looks most like the moment people got the value and explain why.
4. Flag anything where the sample is too small to trust.
No data yet?

Talk to your first paying customers. Ask what they did first and when they knew it was worth paying for. Their answers point to the action.

02STEP · CUT EVERYTHING IN BETWEEN

What's standing between sign-up and that action?

Once you know the action, sign up to your own product as a brand-new user. Write down every screen, field and click before you reach it. Most products ask for far more than they need on day one: job titles, company size, profile photos, preferences, a tour. Every one of those is a place to leave.

What this looked like for Xeruit

"For us, it was removing a lot of forms. You go straight into filling your username, uploading your CV and applying for jobs. We don't care about anything else."

Cut it
Anything you're collecting just in case. If you don't use it in the first session, don't ask for it.
Move it
Things you do need, like billing details or team invites. Ask for them after the user has reached the action.
Keep it
Only the steps the action can't happen without.
prompt for claude
Here's every step in my sign-up flow, from the landing page to [THE ACTION], in order:
[paste the list of screens and fields]
For each step, tell me whether to cut it, move it to after [THE ACTION] or keep it, with one line on why. Then write the shortest possible flow from sign-up to [THE ACTION] and the copy for each screen that's left.

Count the steps before and after. The aim is the fewest clicks between signing up and the action.

03STEP · THE VERY IMPORTANT ONE

Who reaches that action in their first session?

A user who reaches the action in their first session has seen why your product exists. One who doesn't might never come back to find out. So this is the number to watch: of the people who signed up, how many reached the action before they left?

signed_up
When they joined and where they came from.
the_action
When they first did the thing you found in step 1.
first_session
Yes or no. Work it out from the gap between the two, for example the action within 30 minutes of signing up.
paid
When they started paying, so you can check the action really does lead to paying.

Simple tools are fine. A product analytics tool lets you send these as events and build a funnel from sign-up to the action. If you're not there yet, a spreadsheet works: one row per sign-up, a column for each event time and a yes/no column for the first session.

prompt for claude
My app is built with [your stack]. I want to track whether new users reach [THE ACTION] in their first session.
1. Add these events, each with a user ID and timestamp: signed_up, [the_action], paid.
2. Mark a user as first-session activated if [the_action] happens within [30] minutes of signed_up.
3. Send the events to [your analytics tool]. If I don't have one, write them to a table I can export as a spreadsheet.
4. Give me a weekly view: sign-ups, how many reached [THE ACTION] in their first session and how many of those went on to pay.
Show me the changes before you make them.
Read it every week

When you change the flow in step 2, this is the number that tells you whether it worked. If it goes up and paying users follow, keep the change.

THE TAKEAWAY

What should you change this week?

Don't rebuild your whole product. Find the action, cut one step in front of it and start counting who gets there in their first session.

Your price is usually never the problem. Most sign-ups never get to that paywall.

Use Claude Code for more than your app

Edit Your Videos with Claude Code · Opus 5.5: describe the edit in plain English and Claude Code writes the Remotion code that builds it.

The Storyboard-First Edit: the framework to paste into Claude Code to trim a raw take, set a look and approve real frames before anything renders.

What this guide won't do: it won't set up your tracking for you and it won't promise you a conversion rate. The 3,000 sign-ups came from one pre-launch ad campaign and they're not a benchmark. Every product's key action is different, so test what you find before you rebuild around it.

Building something of your own?

The Audacity to Build is my community for people doing exactly that. It is opening soon. Join the waitlist and you are first in when it does.

Come and find me

If this was useful, follow me. I share what I am actually building, the tools that survive my own testing, and the ones I quietly cancel. New plays every week.

Fadé AdeniyiFadé & The Machines